Today, I want to try and think about why it is that radical anti-capitalist ideas are tolerated in universities so much more than anywhere else. In contrast to a lot of my posts, this doesn’t have much to do with current events, it’s more a general attempt to work out an idea.
Anyway, in general this society isn’t incredibly tolerant of dissent. It’s not the most repressive regime that’s ever existed, but it’s also a long way from real freedom of speech. If you want to protest peacefully at the wrong time – say, during a royal wedding – you’re likely to face heavy repression, and while critical ideas are given some limited space in a few papers (Independent, Guardian, Mirror), most of the press forms a solidly right-wing consensus. There is an obvious reply to this, which is that this is just the law of supply and demand playing itself out, and if lefty papers were more appealing then they’d outsell the Sun, but if you think about for a second this idea is obviously bullshit: millions of people don’t read the Evening Standard (notorious for its ridiculous scare stories about anarchists) and the Metro (owned by the same people as the Daily Mail) every day because they think those are the best papers around, or because they’ve sought them out, it’s because millions of those papers are distributed free to commuters every day. There’s no anti-establishment paper with anything like the resources to be able to compete with that, and so our formal freedom of speech is drowned out by the fact that the owners of right-wing papers can shout thousands of times louder than we can.
Anyway, compared to the near-total blackout of radical ideas in most of the media, it’s notable how easy a time they have in the academic world. Universities offer courses like Peace Studies, Critical Theory After Marx, Activism and Social Change, and so on, and there are radical professors ranging from Alex Callinicos and Slavoj Zizek to Antonio Negri and David Graeber. With the decline of interest in Marxism after the fall of the Soviet Union, a Foucault-flavoured post-modernism with a vague opposition to “power” is the most fashionable brand of radical thought, but the existence of the Anarchist Studies Network proves that there’s enough room for anarchist ideas within the ivory towers. The image of the student radical is a cliche, but it’s one with some truth to it – hardly surprising, when universities allow socialist and anarchist groups to operate openly in a way that no workplace would. So why is it that the bosses who run universities are generally so unbothered by people promoting ideas that say we should get rid of bosses?
I’d argue that the presence of radical ideas in the universities actually serves as propaganda for capitalism in two related ways. First of all, it serves as an advert for liberal capitalism’s tolerance: when people try to kick up a fuss about police repression of protests, or the absence of radical ideas in the mainstream media, or any of the other authoritarian features of this society, defenders of capitalism can point to the freedom of ideas within academia as proof of how benevolent and open the system is. The flipside of this freedom is that it’s relatively powerless: giving anarchists and socialists space to speak up on a regular basis in the mainstream media, or to organise openly in their workplaces, would carry the risk of their ideas reaching large numbers of working-class people. But most people never reach university, and the majority of those who do are on courses that don’t require them to actively engage with radical ideas, so anti-capitalist critiques mainly tend to reach a limited self-selecting audience who have an interest in those ideas in the first place.
Related to this, the association between revolutionary ideas and the universities can actually be used as a way to attack those ideas and anyone who supports them. As I’ve said, not everyone gets to go to uni, and, without wanting to get into the vexed question of who’s part of the “real working class” and who isn’t, it seems pointless to deny that those who do get the chance tend to be somewhat better off than those who don’t. Similarly, whatever attacks they’re currently facing from university bosses, academics certainly get better pay and conditions than, for example, call centre or retail workers. This means that the connection between radicalism and universities can be used to dismiss any kind of progressive cause and its supporters by painting them as privileged young folk who don’t understand the real world of work. By attacking radicals in this way, it becomes possible to portray supporting inequality and opposing workers’ rights as the sort of sensible, grown-up thing that “real workers” do. This isn’t helped by the tendency of many well-educated revolutionaries, from the Escalate Collective to the Really Open University to Aufheben to the Invisible Committee, to express themselves in very academic language that can be inaccessible to many people who haven’t been to university (and even to a lot of people who have).
To try and preempt any misunderstanding, I’d like to stress that I’m not saying universities hire Marxist academics as part of some deliberate capitalist conspiracy worked out in smoky back rooms, just that some situations develop a logic of their own, and I think the logic of how universities work tends to promote tolerance of radical ideas more than the logic of society in general. Of course, this certainly doesn’t mean that all anti-capitalist academics, and much less students, are enemies who should be fought against – although those, like Alex Callinicos, who use their position in the social hierarchy to try and set themselves up as the leaders who will guide the working class to victory actually are the enemy, and should be treated the same as any other politician seeking to gain power off our backs. Considering how shit most jobs are, I can’t really blame anyone who turns to academia as a way of escaping the grimness of the “real world”. I want to abolish the difference between academics and the rest of the population, but I want to do that by creating a world where everyone will have the freedom to spend lots of time learning about the stuff that interests them, not a world where everyone will be as miserable as the most oppressed wage-slave.
There are no easy answers as to how students and academics who genuinely want to destroy this system can break out of the safe roles it offers them, but one answer might be to try and forge closer links with university support staff. That’s a fairly empty statement in the abstract, but the 2009 SOAS university occupation in solidarity with migrant cleaners (analysed in depth by the Commune) shows what it might look like in practice. It’s easy to dismiss students or lecturers as posh idiots out of touch with the real world, it’s a lot harder to write migrant cleaners making minimum wage or less off in the same way.
News round-up: obviously, the main story of this week’s been the ongoing News of the World scandal, which Adam Ford has an interesting discussion of – Tower Hamlets ALARM want to turn the anger against Murdoch into action with a demo in Wapping tomorrow (as I write this, it’s just been confirmed that the NotW is closing, but that shouldn’t mean that Murdoch gets off the hook). Meanwhile, prisoners’ struggles are kicking off in the US, EDO decommissioner Simon Levin is yet another activist who’s tragically passed away this summer, struggles are going on in Italy, Indonesia and Greece, and two new pamphlets about workplace organising are now free to read online: Weakening the Dam, a Twin Cities IWW piece about helping your co-workers develop into organisers, and Workmates, a SolFed pamphlet looking at a workplace group on the London Underground run according to anarcho-syndicalist principles.
-
Recent Posts
- Statement in support of the protests in Iran
- Strike action at schools, hospitals, colleges, railways and more: workplace/class struggle round-up for early December
- GMB union and Asda accused of collaborating to sack shop steward: #ReinstateMicky update
- Cyber Monday protests at Amazon, action alert for Kevan Thackrar, and more class struggle news and events for early December
- Class struggle events listing, Nov 25-Dec 1st
Recommended reading
- Abolish Restaurants
- Against Nationalism
- As We See It/As We Don't See It
- Breaking Free
- Caring: A Labor of Stolen Time
- Fighting for Ourselves
- Introduction to Anarchist Communism
- Libcom introductory guides
- Nasty, Brutal and Small
- Proletarian management: Informal workplace organisation
- Rebuilding solidarity at the grassroots…
- Spectacular Times
- Take the power back – Breathing space, friendliness and solidarity at work
- To Change Everything
- We Are All Very Anxious
- Who Is Oakland: Anti-Oppression Activism, the Politics of Safety, and State Co-optation
- Why You Should Start a Solidarity Network
- Work Community Politics War
Recommended listening
Recommended watching
General resources/misc.
- Anarcha Library
- Anarchist bookfairs
- Anarchist Events
- Anarchist FAQ
- Anarchist Media Project
- Anarkismo
- Antidote Zine
- Big Flame
- Black Flag Magazine
- Crimethinc
- Cyberunions
- Datacide
- Dealing with Bailiffs
- Dialectical Delinquents
- Freedom News
- Ideas & Action
- It's Going Down
- Job Seeker Sanction Advice
- Joyful Militancy
- Kate Sharpley Library
- LabourStart
- Libcom
- London Rebel Drivers
- Marxists Internet Archive
- Notes from Below
- Novara Media
- Now Or Never
- Occupy Everything for Everyone
- Organizing Work
- Past Tense
- Platformist archive
- Prole.info
- Recomposition
- Refuted
- Revolt Against Plenty
- Right to Remain toolkit
- Self-Management Notes
- Situationist International text library
- Strike Action
- Strike magazine
- The Acorn
- The Anarchist Library
- The Free Association
- The Free Communist
- The Occupied Times
- Union Solidarity International
- Working Class History
- Workplace Organising
- Zabalaza Books
National groups
- Acorn
- Anarchist Communist Group
- Anarchist Federation
- Angry Workers of the World
- Anti-Fascist Network
- Black Triangle Campaign
- Boycott Workfare
- Class War
- Disabled People Against Cuts
- Feminist Fightback
- Football Lads & Lasses Against Fascism
- Independent Working-Class Association
- Industrial Workers of the World
- Mental Health Resistance Network
- Plan C
- Sisters Uncut
- Solidarity Federation
Blogroll
- Alice B Reckless
- Anarcho-bastard
- Another Angry Woman
- Attempts at Living
- Automatic Writing
- Bastard Octopus
- Burn Shit
- Caiman del Barrio
- Circle A Librarian
- Class(room) War
- Deterritorial Support Group
- Disillusioned Marxist
- Everybody Hates A Tourist
- Floaker
- For Workers' Power
- From the Greek streets
- Grumpy Bootboy
- Highly Heretical
- History is made at night
- Incubus
- Infantile Disorder
- Intensive Activity
- Izzy Koksal
- Johnny Void
- Kate Belgrave
- Life Glug
- Lolrevolution
- Luxcom
- Maid in London
- MC Auter's Musings
- Minor Threat Recordings
- My Arse
- New Syndicalist
- Nice One
- Occupy Everything!
- Pierce Penniless
- Polite Ire
- Poumista
- Property is Theft
- Quacking Plums
- Red Star Commando
- Sanction Sabs
- Sharmanka
- Site Worker
- Steel City Syndicalist
- Still Flying a Black Flag
- Sunderland Echoes
- The Commune
- The Great Unrest
- The Peripheries of Anarchy
- The Resistance Report
- The Revolution Will Be Streamed
- Tinned Dirt
- Tips for Radicals
- Trade Onion
- Truth-Reason-Liberty
- Uncomradely Behaviour
- Unemployed in Tyne & Wear
- Velvet Coalmine
- While Rome Burns
Local groups
- Aberdeen Anarchists
- Action East End
- Anti-Cuts Action Bristol and Bath
- Anti-Raids Network (London)
- Autonomous Nottingham
- BARF (Bath anarchist group)
- Brent Solidarity Group
- Bristol AF
- Bristol Care Workers Network
- Bristol IWW
- Bristol Solidarity Network
- Community Action Lewisham
- Dorset IWW
- Edinburgh Anarcha-feminists
- Edinburgh Anarchists
- Forest of Dean anarchists
- Glasgow Anarchists
- Glasgow Solidarity Network
- Hackney Anarchist Group
- Hackney Solidarity Network
- Haringey Solidarity Group
- Hereford Heckler
- Leicester Anarchist Communists
- Leicestershire Solidarity Group
- Liverpool Class Action
- Liverpool IWW
- Liverpool Solidarity Federation
- London Anarchist Bookfair
- London Anarchist Communists
- London Anarchist Federation
- London Coalition Against Poverty
- Manchester (and sometimes Sheffield) bookfair
- Manchester AF
- Manchester IWW
- Norfolk Community Action Group
- North East Anarchists
- Norwich Bartenders and Hospitality Union
- Norwich SolFed
- Nottingham Solidarity Network
- Nottinghamshire Black Arrow
- Notts IWW
- Portsmouth Anarchists
- Rabble LDN
- Radical Islington
- Radical London
- Red and Black Leeds
- Scottish AF
- Scottish IWW
- Sheffield Autonomous Students
- Sheffield IWW
- South Essex Stirrer
- South Wales Anarchists
- Staines Anarchists
- Stuff Your Boss (Newcastle SolFed)
- Surrealist London Action Group
- Surrey Anarchist Communists
- Surrey and Hampshire Anarchist Federation
- Teeside Solidarity Movement
- The Fargate Speaker
- The Sparrow's Nest
- The West Country Mutineer
- Wessex Solidarity
- Whitechapel Anarchist Group
- Worthing Anarchists
- York Anarchists
Claimants and unemployed groups
Housing
- Barnet Housing Action Group
- Basildon & Southend Housing Action
- Birmingham Eviction Resistance Network
- Brent Housing Action
- Brum Tenants and Homeless Action Group
- Eviction Resistance (London-based)
- Fight for the Aylesbury
- Focus E15
- Hackney Renters
- Haringey Housing Action Group
- Housing Action Southwark and Lambeth
- Leeds Hands Off Our Homes
- Living Rent
- New Era 4 All
- Radical Housing Network
- Renters Rising
- Sweets Way Resists
- Tower Hamlets Renters
Anti-fascism
- 3 Counties AFA
- Aberdeen AFA
- Berkshire Anti-Fascists
- Brighton Anti-Fascists
- Bristol Antifascists
- East Midlands Anti-Fascists
- Essex Antifa
- Leeds Anti-Fascist Network
- Liverpool Antifascists
- London Antifascists
- North-East Anti-Fascists
- Portsmouth Antifascists
- Sheffield Anti-Fascist Network
- South London Anti-Fascists
- Southampton Antifa
- Welsh Antifa
- West Yorkshire 161
Prisoners/Legal Support/Anti-Repression
- Brighton ABC
- Bristol ABC
- Bristol Defendant Solidarity
- Campaign Opposing Police Surveilance
- Cardiff ABC
- Community Action on Prison Expansion
- Empty Cages Collective
- Glasgow Defence Campaign
- Green & Black Cross
- Incarcerated Workers Organising Committee
- Leeds Anarchist Black Cross
- Legal Defence & Monitoring Group
- London Anarchist Black Cross
- London Campaign Against Police & State Violence
- Network for Police Monitoring
- Orgreave Truth & Justice Campaign
- Police spies out of lives
- Prisoner Solidarity
- Rotherham 12 Campaign
- Smash IPP
- Special Branch Files Project
- Support Prisoner Resistance (US)
- Undercover Research Group
Archives
- December 2019
- November 2019
- October 2019
- September 2019
- August 2019
- July 2019
- June 2019
- May 2019
- April 2019
- March 2019
- February 2019
- January 2019
- December 2018
- November 2018
- October 2018
- September 2018
- August 2018
- July 2018
- June 2018
- May 2018
- April 2018
- March 2018
- February 2018
- January 2018
- December 2017
- November 2017
- October 2017
- September 2017
- August 2017
- July 2017
- June 2017
- May 2017
- April 2017
- March 2017
- February 2017
- January 2017
- December 2016
- November 2016
- October 2016
- September 2016
- August 2016
- July 2016
- June 2016
- May 2016
- April 2016
- March 2016
- February 2016
- January 2016
- December 2015
- November 2015
- October 2015
- September 2015
- August 2015
- July 2015
- June 2015
- May 2015
- April 2015
- March 2015
- February 2015
- January 2015
- December 2014
- November 2014
- October 2014
- September 2014
- August 2014
- July 2014
- May 2014
- April 2014
- March 2014
- February 2014
- January 2014
- December 2013
- November 2013
- October 2013
- September 2013
- June 2013
- May 2013
- April 2013
- March 2013
- February 2013
- January 2013
- December 2012
- November 2012
- October 2012
- September 2012
- August 2012
- July 2012
- June 2012
- May 2012
- April 2012
- March 2012
- February 2012
- January 2012
- December 2011
- November 2011
- October 2011
- September 2011
- August 2011
- July 2011
- June 2011
- May 2011
- April 2011
- March 2011
- February 2011
- January 2011
- December 2010
- November 2010
- October 2010
- September 2010
Categories
- Activism
- Anarchists
- Bit more thinky
- Climate Change
- Debate
- Disability
- Gender
- Housing
- Internationalism
- Internet
- Know your rights
- Labour
- Occupations
- Protests
- Racism
- Repression
- Riots
- Strikes
- Students
- Stuff that I don't think is very useful
- Stuff that I think is pretty awesome
- The left
- The media
- The right
- Tories
- Uncategorized
- Unemployment/claimants and welfare
- Unions
- Work
Meta